|
|
La Ienti de Sion: Linguistic and Cultural Legacy of an Early Thirteenth-Century Judeo-Italian KinahForward | Italian Jewry | Hebrew | Literature | The Kinah | Manuscripts | Language | Analysis | Conclusion Forward The
People of Zion on Italian Soil: We find Jewish settlements in Italy already in the second century before the Vulgar Era. Cecil Roth, in his The History of the Jews of Italy, refers to the Jewish presence in the peninsula as "indeed of profound antiquity [...] its Jewish communities are older than even its most venerable corporations; and if there is now in Rome any institution more ancient than the Papacy, it is the Synagogue."6 Substantiated by historical data and archaeological findings, it is believed that the first Jewish settlements were in Rome and to its south, along the trade routes and in the southern ports,7 which functioned as a link with the Eastern Mediterranean mercantile posts. These small communities of both free men and slaves, were made of artisans, merchants, weavers, dyers, and farmers. Their way of life shows a high degree of cultural assimilation to the local customs, including the language.8 In the year 70 of the Vulgar Era, with the fall of Jerusalem, Titus put an end to the political unity of the Jewish people. A great number of Jews from Palestine were enslaved and sent to Italy. The majority was dispatched to Rome, the others were scattered throughout the South: Taranto, Otranto, Oria, and Bari. Such forced emigration increased the Jewish presence in Italy, mainly augmenting and reinforcing its ancient settlements. By the end of the Classical period, Jewish presence is found throughout the whole Italian Peninsula, Sicily, and Sardinia. Cecil Roth, rightfully ascertains that: "every sizable town in Italy had its Jewish community before the decay of the Roman Empire in the West."9 Besides Rome, which, since the beginning, has always had the largest concentration of Jewish population, there are, to its north Falerii, Chiusi, Genoa, Tortona, Milan, Brescia, Concordia, Aquileia, and Pola. To the south of Rome there are, instead, the ancient cities of Capua, Naples, Pozzuoli, Pompei, Bari, Otranto, Oria, and Taranto. In Sicily there is evidence of Jewish presence in Syracuse, Palermo, Catania, Messina, and Agrigento. However things really deteriorated with the Christianization of the Empire in the fourth century. The state of the Jew was one of subjection, oftentimes protected, though unwillingly, by the Pope of the time against violence and brutal excesses. As a whole, however, the basic fundamental human rights of the Jew were maintained. The fifth and the sixth centuries were much of the same: discrimination and hostility but all contained. Little is known about the daily life of the Jews residing in Italy during these first centuries of the Vulgar Era. Even less is known about their cultural and intellectual life. With the exception of the works of Josephus,10 and Mattiah ben Heresh11 no literary activity within the Judeo-Italian communities is to be found until the ninth century. We are left only with ruins of synagogues and tomb inscriptions in Greek and Latin, in which only sporadically some Hebrew words appear, such as Salom, Salom el Ysrael, all coupled with pagan symbols or with a menorah. Once again, this is an indication of poor schooling in Hebrew versus the high degree of assimilation to the local culture(s). Political and social events of the eighth and ninth centuries will deeply affect Italian Jewry, its daily life, as well as its cultural aspect. The migration of Jews from North Africa, escaping the Muslim grip, had as its main consequence an increasing renewed interest in Hebrew and Hebrew studies as a whole. It was a revival of their culture, of their forgotten living language: thus the birth of rabbinical schools and the increasing production of works in Hebrew. Soon, by the end of the tenth century Italian Jews came to be regarded as highly educated and well trained in religious matters. It should also be noted that the Jewish communities residing in Italy have always been in close contact with Palestine and it was mainly from these southern Italian towns that the Palestinian tradition could be introduced and then transmitted to the rest of Europe. Italy, and in particular the whole South, including Sicily, can boast of its ancient schools of religious poetry in Hebrew: "the earliest in Europe, if not the earliest outside Palestine."12 Only by bearing this in mind, can we then understand a twelfth-century scholar, when he, using as his model Isaiah 2:3,13 said: "from Bari comes forth the Law, and the word of God from Otranto."14 As we have seen, then, at the end of the first millennium and in the early Middle Ages, southern Italy is the irradiating place for Jewish culture. However, things begin to change. At the end of the thirteenth century, persecution in the Kingdom of Naples15 left many Jews with either conversion to Christianity or exile, i.e., migrating north: Rome, Central and Northern Italy. After a century, Jewish life in Southern Italy, except for Sicily, was almost entirely eradicated, having lost its past splendor and fame, never to be regained. From now on, Jewish settlements are to be found in Rome and to its north. In the meantime, the great trading cities of central and northern Italy begin to free themselves from the remote, indirect control of the German Empire, thus managing to organize themselves into semi-autonomous independent states. The Jews residing here, to the north of Rome, are mainly merchants and traders, especially in the great Italian republics, such as Pisa and Genoa. Before the thirteenth century, however, only to a few Jews permanent or temporary residence to the north of Rome was allowed.16 This attitude was the result of fear of economic competition rather than a religious bias. Gradually, though, in the following two centuries things lead to a change, to the invitation of Jewish settlements within their cities, due partly to the Catholic Church. For a long time the Church had been very adamant in its crusade against Christian usury. It was precisely at this point that many central and northern Italian cities began to invite Jewish loan bankers. The need for capital was great, and Jewish money lenders served the purpose. Thus the end of the thirteenth century figures as the turning point for such "internal Diaspora." The People of Zion move north. They make their appearance in central and northern Italy, living in close contact with the goim, in the cities, and countryside.17 Of the central Italian geographico-political regions, the Marche and Umbria, due to geographical contiguity, successfully manage to maintain their cultural ties with the Jewish community in Rome. The Jews already residing in these central and northern Italian towns18 hence open up the way for new migrations. These new immigrants were Jews, but they were also "Italians" speaking a vernacular which had at its roots Latin. Therefore, assimilation to other Italian Jews was not difficult, and instead of drastic linguistic consequences, it created a linguistic compromise. Life and culture of Italian Jews in these first three centuries of the second millennium thus reflect these deep changes-mainly political-that touched the Italian Peninsula as a whole. Hebrew Post-biblical
Literature The first Jewish Italian piyyutim were composed in southern Italy.22 From the south, paitanic activity spread to Rome and then to central and northern Italy. The piyyutim are divided into classes, special categories, according to their topic, contents, and place within the liturgy. There was also the kinah, an elegy often associated with the services and the religious functions of the month of Av. Various elegiac poems of this type were written in the Middle Ages. Perhaps the most famous of all is the Sionim-i.e., Odes to Zion-composed by Judah ha-Levi.23 In addition, some kinot are present in the Bible: for example, the kinah of David honoring Saul and Jonathan in II Samuel I: 19-27, and in Lamentations, in Hebrew Eiknah,) was also known as the Book of Kinot. The first kinot were used for lamenting the death of family leaders or of whole nations (Genesis 23:2; Jeremiah 22:18; Zaccariah 12:10). With time, gradually, the kinot were also recited when major calamities struck the Nation, i.e., the people of Zion. The ninth of Av-Tishah be-Av-is the saddest day in the Jewish calendar. In the Talmud (Numbers 13-14) God designated the ninth of Av as a day of calamity because of the lack of faith in His promises to rescue them from the wilderness: "You wept without a cause; I will therefore make this an eternal day of mourning for you." It was then decreed that on the ninth of Av the Holy Temple would be destroyed and the People of Zion would go into exile and not enter the Land of Israel (Numbers 14:29). The Mishnah (Ta'an 4:6) tells us of five disasters that happened on this day: a. after their Exodus from Egypt, the people of Israel would never enter the Promised Land; b. the first destruction of the Holy Temple by Nebuchadnezzar, (586 b.V.E.); c. the second destruction o the Holy Temple by Titus, (70 V.E.); d. the fortress-city of Bethar seized in 135 V.E.. with the massacre of Bar Kokhba and his men; e. 136 V.E., Jerusalem is renamed Aelia Capitolina, and the Holy Temple becomes a pagan temple.24 Such a day, then, has ultimately become the utmost symbol for all persecutions and calamities that have befallen upon the chosen people. The synagogue service begins, after sundown, with the Ma'ariv25 followed by the reading and chanting of the Book of Lamentations. At the end of Lamentations, the next-to-last verse is repeated by everyone because of the hopeful note of its message: "Turn us unto You, o Lord, and we shall be turned, renew our days of old." Following the Book of Lamentations, there is the recital of a series of piyyutim. These prayers, known also as kinot, describe the destruction of the Temple and portray the sins of the Jewish people. The last kinah is entitled Eli Tzion Ha-lo tishali, (Sweet singer of Zion), and is sung to a well-known melody. Yehudah Ha-Levi composed this poem. It sings of the restoration of Zion: a hope that has been cherished by every generation of Jews. The verses speak eloquently of Israel and of the pains of Galut. Many kinot for the ninth of Av start with the word Zion, including the Judeo-Italian Kinah. The Italian rite, among other things, includes also the Nahem for the blessings and the restoration of Jerusalem. The
Judeo-Italian Kinah: La ienti de Sion The Italian Kinah is divided into three parts: 1.) an initial introduction of 48 verses-it is the lamentation for the massacre and the following Diaspora, (Galut), of the chosen people; 2.) a medial section, of also 48 verses-it concentrates on only one episode of the Galut; 3.) and a final, conclusive part, of only 24 verses-it is the invocation to God, the hope, the fervent desire for the reconstruction of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem. Verses 1-48 recount the many regrets of the Chosen People, the People of Zion. They have lost the glory of their past, the blessings of the Lord. The Temple, now destroyed, is the main object of the Lamentation, along with all the misadventures that it caused. Israel suffers, it is being mocked. All this is narrated in very generic terms, without any specific reference to the Scriptures. Only verses 37-39 recall a particular episode of the Talmud and the Midrashic literature. Verses 49-96 concentrate on the argument of the Elegy. The topic is a religious one, tinged with folklorist elements. The main story is taken from the Midrash and the Talmud. There are two versions: one from the Midrash Ekka Rabba, the other from the Babylonian Talmud. There is also a third version, in the Midrash Ekka Zuta, however this one is a derivatio of the Babylonian Talmud. The other two, instead, besides a few differences and small details, are very similar to each other.26 It seems that the author of the Elegy knew both versions, especially the Midrash Ekka Rabba. In fact, from the latter he appropriates almost all of the story. This could in part be due to the story being orally transmitted-through the centuries-and then recorded into folklore books. Verses 97-120 end the Elegy. Here we have the prayer, direct and explicit, to the Lord. It is a wonderful plea to the Lord, so that He may pour once again those abundant blessings which He used to bestow upon His people in the past. It is the People of Zion here who talk, those Chosen by the Lord. The world has to return to its original setting: the enemies-the goim-on one hand and Israel on the other. This is the only hope, surpassed only by the joy of the Lord, by the fulfillment of the prophesy: the return to Israel, seeing Zion, entering into Jerusalem. Such ending is typical of pan-Hebraic kinot on the ninth of Av. Past and present calamities are lamented. But there is the gracious hope for tomorrow, the future "prophesied by the prophet." (v. 117) The
Manuscripts The language is central or central-southern Italian. However, we do not have enough data-linguistic and/or historical-to determine its collocation in time and geo-linguistic space. Attached to the Elegy were found some selicoth-i.e., penitential hymns-which refer to historical events of the Jewish community in Rome. This could prove that the Elegy might have been written in Rome or in any of those small Jewish communities of central Italy in close religious and cultural contacts with Rome. Of the two manuscripts, the first one belonging to the Temple of Ferrara was found with the vowels possibly added by the same scribe. However, the great majority of them are gone and there are also many errors of transcriptions which make the interpretation very hard. Oftentimes there are corrections, usually written over or above the text. Such orthographic errors could be a good indication that, by this time, the scribe already was not understanding well the text from which he was copying. The second text, found at Parma, is made of two different manuscripts. The Kinah is contained in the first volume, following some prayers for the fast of the ninth of Av, as part of a regular Machzor in Hebrew. This text has only the consonants. Its vowels were added later and perhaps not even by the same scribe. This copy has less mistakes and seems closer to the original Elegy. Both texts are not copies of one another; instead they derive from a common archetype, be it directly or indirectly, which, it seems, was itself not void of mistakes. The tercets-with each metrical line made of four words-have only one rhyme meter. The verses have asymmetrical syllables in which neither the number nor the position of the atonic syllable are taken into account. There is a constant though: to the last tonic syllable follows an atonic. Therefore the verses are paroxytones. However, the composer does not follow this pattern all the way through: in such cases there are only three accented words. The
Language There are some scholars, mainly in the past, including Umberto Cassuto, who firmly believe in a Roman-based Jewish-Italian koiné which later spread throughout the peninsula, wherever Jewish communities were to be found, eventually modifying and dividing itself according to the phonetic differences of the new locations. This koiné would have therefore been the common ancestor of all the Jewish settlers in Italy, becoming then a means of communication denoting an antique homogeneity.30 Therefore, talking about Judeo-Italian dialects (languages) is talking about the languages of the places where each Jewish community lived. A Jewish-Italian and a goy when speaking would differ only in the lexical choice pertaining to his/her religious expressions and/or other linguistic archaisms, mainly due to centuries-old segregations. Here and there linguistic fusions will be found, where to the Hebrew root the local Italian "vernacular" gender marker is added or where some Hebrew verbal forms adapt to the Italian model. But besides these peculiarities, which by the way are quite minimal, Judeo-Italian is well integrated, linguistically indivisible, and practically the same with the language of the goyim of that given region and/or geographico-political area.31 Linguistic
Analysis In the pan-Hebraic world, the person who would usually recite the kinot was the sofed or, in the case of a woman, the mekonen, (Ecclesiastes 12:5; Jeremiah 9:16;19) and oftentimes they themselves would compose them. Our Judeo-Italian composer, writing in "vernacular," was addressing the audience. Umberto Cassuto called him a sheliach zibbur,32 i.e., a person who would celebrate. A shaliach is a knowledgeable person who knows the Law. His task is to help the believers in understanding the Scriptures and other religious matters. It is very possible, then, that this Italian shaliach could have also sung the Elegy amongst the whole congregation. And this would explain the use of the vernacular within the literary pattern. He resembles, in his style, the minstrel, the medieval traveling poet and musician. The lexicon and the way he addresses his audience evoke the ballad singer. Whether this is conscious imitation or just evidence of strong influences of popular compositions of religious minstrels, it certainly talks about the language and the influence of this itinerant poetry upon the early Italian literature, where secular and religious aspects are intertwined, inseparable. From the phonological point of view the Kinah reflects dialectal features of central and southern Italy. However, as Giuliana Fiorentino has also noted, there is not "a single specific and more typical fact would permit a precise localization."33 There are a few dialectal features that blatantly reveal their central and/or southern origin:
Concerning its lexicon, what makes it different from other forms, or rather, other "local" vernaculars and "standard" Italian, are specific words pertaining to religion, not many, and a few linguistic calques, i.e., loan translations into the vernacular of a concept, an idea, originally non existent in situ-in the local language(s)-but used in Hebrew. There are also some translations, even literal, new ways of saying, or new meanings given to "old" ones-i.e., pre-existing and currently used-words:
Some religious Judaic words are also found in Italian: e.g., Sion, Israel, Deo, Templo, Santo, Sacerdoti, Leviti. In the midst of the narration, our shaliach calls the attention of his listeners, crying:
The composer interrupts the narration and addressing his audience, talks, either directly or indirectly, as a true medieval minstrel.35 In the following two tercets he poses these two questions:
ki grandi cordoglio no li prindisse, e grande lamento no ne facisse? Ki poe contare l'altri tormenti, ki spisso spisso so convenenti, plo dori ke flambi ardenti?36 or, a bit earlier in the narration, he sneaks in the innuendo:
çença rimo (entenda ki sa iutare!)38 Here he calls upon the listeners' judgment, he wants them to listen, to think, to ponder, and, most of all, to fear God and the consequences of His wrath, and at the same time to have pity over His people. Hence, as we have seen, the pagan, the strictly non-religious model was there: non-Hebraic in nature, and religious and secular at times. It was part of life, of the European culture of that time. The shaliach relegates all this in the background, thus reconstructing a new image, forging a new system upon which to sing and lament the story of his people. Final
Remarks Go To the Text (Transcription in Latin Characters)40 Notes 1. Italy and Italian are here used in their geographico-historical meaning, comprising the Italian Peninsula proper, Sicily, Sardinia, and other regions and/or cities once part of the Roman Empire, and now politically not part of Italy, e.g., Nice, Pola, Spalato, just to name a few which, off and on, throughout the centuries, shared the same fate of their Italian counterparts. 2. In this case, one or more central Italian dialect(s). 3. The years in the Jewish calendar are counted "since the Creation." However, according to chronological calculations based upon internal evidence from the Bible, the beginning—i.e., the Creation—might have occurred in the year 3761 B.C., or rather, 5758 years ago. According another computation, done by Byzantine theologians, Creation only started 5513 years ago! In daily practice the thousands are not enumerated, therefore the Jewish year is often represented starting with the hundreds onwards. The letters of the Hebrew alphabet are used to represent the cardinal numbers and each letter of the Hebrew alphabet has its own numerical equivalent. The year in the Judaic system is made of 12 lunar months; however, the festivities—i.e., the religious holidays—follow the solar system. This is due to the fact that some of these holidays—e.g., Pesah, (the Jewish Passover), Shavu'ot and Sukkot—must occur during particular seasons, and the seasons are determined by the annual revolutions of the earth as it turns around the Sun. A lunar year is made of almost 345 and 1/3 days, while a solar year contains approximately 365 and 1 ½ days, or almost eleven days more, hence the Jewish holidays would fall within the wrong seasons—i.e.: during months not allowed by the religious law—if they were to follow the regular cycle of the lunar months. In order to prevent these difficulties, the lunar calendar is always emended so that it can keep these conformities with the solar system. This is possible through the periodical introduction of a 13th month, called Adar Bet—i.e., Adar the Second, or Adar II—right after the regular month Adar, which, during leap year is called Adar Alef—i.e., Adar the First, or Adar I. During nineteen years this discrepancy between the lunar and the solar month sums up to a total of 207 days. Therefore, Adar Bet, Adar II, is introduced to the 3rd, 6th, 8th, 11th, 14th, 17th, and 19th , every nineteen years. Here is a list of the months of the Jewish calendar together with the approximate equivalent in the Gregorian calendar—i.e., the common calendar used today throughout the entire world—and the approximate duration of each one of them. The asterisk indicates that the month only occurs during leap year:
Cf. Isaac Klein. A Guide to Jewish Religious Practice, 256-259; Hayim Baltsam. Hebrew Dictionary. Hebrew/English. English/Hebrew; Lavinia Cohn-Sherbok, and Dan Cohn-Sherbok. A Popular Dictionary of Judaism; Shimshon Inbal. English-Hebrew. Hebrew-English Pocket Dictionary; Angel Sáenz-Badillos. A History of the Hebrew Language. 4. Following are a few terms designating some geographical groups of the Jews of the Diaspora: i. Ashkenazic: relating to the Jews of Germany, Austria, the German canton in Switzerland, Central Europe, and their descendants in Central and Eastern Europe, and elsewhere in the world. Technically, it applied to Jews whose native tongue and/or place of origin was German and/or a German speaking area, a Slavic language and/or area, Romanian, Moldavian, Hungarian and/or Finno-Ugrian; ii. Bani/Beni Israel: relating to the Jews of India and their descendants elsewhere in the world; iii. Falashah: relating to the Jews of Ethiopia and their descendants elsewhere in the world; iv. Italkian: relating to the Jews of Italy, including the Italo-phone parts of Switzerland, Slovenia, Malta, southern France, Corsica, and their descendants elsewhere in the world; v. Maaravic: relating to the Jews of north-western Africa and their descendants elsewhere in the world; vi. Sabra: relating to the Jews from—i.e., born in—Israel; vii. Sephardic: relating to the Jews of the Iberian Peninsula (e.g., Portugal and Spain) and their descendants elsewhere in the world; viii. Temanic: relating to the Jews of southern Arabia and their descendants elsewhere in the world; ix. Yevanic: relating to the Jews of ancient Mediterranean Greek-speaking regions, of the Balkans, of past and present Greece, and their descendants elsewhere in the world; x. Zarphatic: relating to the Jews of northern France and their descendants elsewhere in the world. Cf. Yosef A. A. ben-Jochannan. We The Black Jews. 1983; Solomon A. Birnbaum. The Hebrew Scripts. Part Two: The Plates; Solomon A. Birnbaum. The Hebrew Scripts. Part One: The Text; Joseph Abraham Levi. "Afonso X, o Sábio, as ciências "islâmicas," o papel de Afonso X na difusão dessas ciências e o "Liuro conplido en o[s] juízos das estrelas." Possíveis conexões entre o "Libro conplido en los iudizios de las estrellas" e uma versão portuguesa do século XV escrita em caracteres hebraicos, o Bodleian Library MS. Laud Or. 310," 182-183. 5. Cf. Luciano Tas. Storia degli ebrei italiani, 14-15. 6. Cecil Roth. The History of the Jews of Italy, 1. 7. E.g., Ostia, Naples, Salerno, Bari, Otranto, Taranto, Venosa, Reggio Calabria. 8. Their presence is attested already in the 2nd century B.C. 9. Cecil Roth. The History of the Jews of Italy, 21 10. Josephus, (ca. 37-100 A.D.), Jewish historian, involved in the Jewish revolt during the reign of Nero, Roman Emperor from 54 to 68 A.D. Cf. Josephus. The Jewish War. Trans. G.A. Williamson. 11. Mattiah ben Heresh lived in Rome during the 2nd century A.D. 12. Cecil Roth. The History of the Jews of Italy, 60. 13. Isaiah 11:3 in other traditions. 14. Cecil Roth. The History of the Jews of Italy, 60. 15. Under Angevin rule, 1266-1302. 16. E.g., Milan, Ferrara, Bologna, Forlì, Padua, Perugia, Urbino. 17. Goy, plural, goyim: non-Jewish. 18. E.g., Milan, Ferrara, Bologna, Forlì, Padua, Perugia, Urbino, and Ancona. 19. Synagogues. 20. Cf. the Makré Dardeké, published in Naples in 1488 by Frebat Pérez, a Franco-Catalan Jew. This biblical glossary explicates, in alphabetical order, old and forgotten Hebrew etyma into the vernacular Italian, Hebrew, and Arabic. Cf. Giuliana Fiorentino. "Note lessicali al Maqré Dardeqé," 138-159; Giuliana Fiorentino. "The General Problems of the Judeo-Romance in the Light of the Maqré Dardeqé," 57-77; Moisé Schwab, ed. and trans. Maqré Dardeqé. 21. Piyyut: liturgical poem written in Hebrew. 22. Oria. 23. Spanish doctor, philosopher and poet, 1085-1140. He believed in the return of his People to Zion. His Ode became part of the liturgy for the ninth of Av. Other poems—more than 300—were also introduced in various rites. 24. Furthermore, there are two other major events that also happened on the ninth of Av: in 1290 Edward I, 1239-1307, king of England, 1272-1307, signed the decree expelling the Jews from England; 1492, over 150,000 Jews were expelled from Spain. 25. Evening service, recited daily after nightfall. It is one of the three basic daily prayers. 26. Cf. Umberto Cassuto. "Un'antichissima elegia in dialetto giudeo-italiano," 358-363. 27. Maybe because it was part of a Machzor, a complete cycle of prayers for the whole year including piyyutim for special Shabbats and other annual holy festivities used in the synagogues, therefore written completely and solely in Hebrew. 28. Umberto Cassuto. "Un'antichissima elegia in dialetto giudeo-italiano," 382. 29. Gerolamo Lazzeri. Antologia dei primi secoli della letteratura italiana, 181. 30. This could be true but one should also bear in mind the historical and political events that have characterized and conditioned Italy. Since its very beginning, Italy has always been a divided country, in all the senses. Geography and history have therefore divided the Jewish communities—as with the Italian regions—hence preventing the formation of a strong, unified koiné, as in the case of Yiddish and, on a lesser scale, Ladino. 31. Cf. Giovanna Massariello Merzagora. Il giudeo-italiano: dialetti italiani parlati dagli ebrei d'Italia; Cesare Segre. "Benvenuto Terracini, linguistica e le parlate giudeo-italiane,"499-506. 32. Umberto Cassuto. "Un'antichissima elegia in dialetto giudeo-italiano," 388. 33. Giuliana Fiorentino. "The General Problems of the Judeo-Romance in the Light of the Maqré-Dardeqé," 57-77; Joseph Sermoneta. "Considerazioni frammentarie sul giudeo-italiano,"1-29. 34. He who wants to hear cruelty. (v. 49). 35. Cf. Gerolamo Lazzeri. Antologia dei primi secoli della letteratura italiana, 182. 36. These cruel deeds having heard, Who would not be struck by sadness, Thus starting great tribulations? Who can count the many torments, That so many times have befallen, Caused by the pain of burning flames? (vv. 91-96). 37. How can we even start telling how. (v. 36). 38. Without oars (may he who knows how to help listen!). (v. 38). 39. Gianfranco Contini. Poeti del Duecento, 15-28. 40.Umberto Cassuto. "Un'antichissima elegia in dialetto giudeo-italiano," 393; 395; 397; 399; 401; 403. © 1998, 2001 Joseph Abraham Levi Send mail concerning this page to: Seth Jerchower, webmaster or Joseph Abraham Levi, Author Last update: Sunday, 11-Feb-2001 19:03:01 EST | ||||||